Sunday, October 21, 2012

In the Service of What?

In the Service of What? The Politics of Service Learning by: Joseph Kahne and Joel Westheimer
Talking Points #6
Hyperlinks: 
Service Learning is a teaching and learning strategy that involves community service with instructions and reflection to enrich the learning experience, teach civic responsibility, and strengthen communities. That is the definition of Service Learning from the link above.  According to the article, service learning makes students active participants in service projects that aim to respond to the needs of the community while furthering the academic goals of students.  The link above showed many examples of service learning projects that were done.  The first one was Elementary Students in Florida studied the consequences of natural disasters. Then they designed a kit for families to use to collect important papers in case of an evacuation.  Another example from the link above was how middle school students in Pennsylvania learned about the health consequences of unhealthy eating, and lack of exercise.  They brought their knowledge together by creating health fairs, creating healthy cookbooks, and opening a fruit and vegetable stand.  Much like our article a portion of it had to do with two service learning cases.  The first one had to do with a twelth grade class who studied issues surrounding democracy and citizenship.  The teacher allowed the students to participate in community service projects of their choosing.  The second case was a little different.  The middle school class identified issues of common concern, and then they voted to focus their attention on just one issue, and that issue they came up with was homelessness.  The service learning examples from my link is an example of change service learning in my opinion. I think that because they created health fairs and tried to impact the community.  The first example of service learning from our article was more charity because they were just doing a good deed.  An example of a change service learning project from our article was when some of the upper-middle class students went and performed music at an elementary school.  They impacted their community, and also their perspectives on the elementary school children had changed it wasn't as bad as they thought. 
I remember in high school we had to do a service learning project in order to graduate.  We had to do 15 hours of some sort of service and then write an essay about it.  I did recycling for my high school.  I feel like I got nothing out of it, and I didn't really help anyone.  My school needs to come up with something better so we could have really helped the community.  The service learning we are doing for our class is so much better.  We are actually helping students in a certain subject area, for me its math, that really need help in school.  I feel like I am making an impact on the students I work with, and I feel accomplished and happy that I can help. 
This is a link to youtube video about service learning.  It shows a lot of service learning examples like above.  It also shows how students have to learn something, then teach it to other people in their community.  They have to struggle to learn something, and change the students roles for once.  It gets them involved with other people in their community.  They are engaged, and they are problem solving.  They are not only helping others, they are learning while they do this.  While we do are service learning for our class, we are making an impact on these students, but we are also learning how to become good teachers.  This video also shows that Service learning really does work! The students also love doing this service learning projects.  A quote from the article we read shows 90% of 14-17 year olds who had been asked to volunteer said yes.  That shows that kids really do want to volunteer and help the community, and they enjoy doing it.  A student from the article did a service learning project of serving senior citizens Thanksgiving dinner.  She said that it felt great helping, and she appreciated the chance to help. 
I wanted to put this link in here because it shows how President Obama has pledged to make service a central cause of his administration.  This fits in with our article when President Bush voiced his support for the National Community Services Act of 1990.  I think that what this shows is that no matter if your a democrat or a republican they support service learning.  This is a good thing because it should be accepted by every president that comes into office.  I think that Service Learning should be required for all grade levels: Elementary School, Middle School, High School, and College.  I plan on continuing to do my service learning after this class, and go above and beyond the minimum hours required for RIC.
Comments:  The service learning project that I did for my high school was terrible.  I really wanted to do something that impacted the community.  I did recycling.  That did nothing for me I remember walking around the school collecting the recycle bins, and goofing off.  It shows that my school did not take this project seriously.  I hope that they work on things to improve that, and do real service learning projects like helping students with math in Providence.  I think students would enjoy it, and by the things I've said in this post students do enjoy it.  I'm glad service learning is becoming more widespread, and students really enjoy doing this!

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

Cinderella Ate My Daughter

Cinderella Ate My Daughter by: Peggy Orenstein
Talking Points #5
Extended Comments:
For my talking points blog this week I decided to do an extended comments blog using Brittani's post.  The first thing that she brings up is that Orenstein argues that the current "princess-phase" is anything but natural.  I think that's exactly what Orenstein is arguing she thinks that the princess phase is making young girls see something that is unrealistic.  For example, no one can look as beautiful as they portray the princesses to be, and because you are so beautiful you aren't going to find true love.  Orenstein also thinks that this will eventually damage the girls' self-esteem.  The next point that Brittani brings up is about the toy fair and how all the toys meant for little girls are all in one color, pink.  She really doesn't find it necessary for everything to be in pink, but apparently it will help them sell more products.  It will show to young girls that everything needs to be pink, so they can be seen as feminine or "girly."  Girls should have multiple colors to choose from, not just pink.  Using any different color isn't going to make them any less feminine than they were before.  Girls should choose how they want to be portrayed. 
Another point she brings up is how a research shows that up until the age of 7 that kids still think that their hair, clothing, toys determines your gender. The link I put there goes to an article about the gender stereotype between masculine and feminine.  That is wrong in my opinion, girls or boys shouldn't have to worry about how they dress or what they play with.  Whatever they do is up to them, and it doesn't make them any less of a boy or a girl.  Brittani says, that the author thinks, girls don't need to prove that they are girls, but the Disney princesses make them do this.  I completely agree, young girls are given this image that they have to look beautiful to find true love or wear this big pink dresses to make them look more girly.  It's not true they are sending the wrong message to children.  A child should just be themselves, and they can achieve anything they want. 
Brittani also talked about the Bratz dolls.  I didn't know what the Bratz dolls were until I read this article, but I'm glad that they came up with dolls that don't portray the normal Disney princess image.  I agree with what Brittani and the author are trying to say that these Bratz dolls do not portray the "princess-y" or "barbieish" image. 
At the end of Brittani's blog she asks the question who's to blame, the parents, the industry or both?  To answer that question I think that they are both to blame.  The parents think that their children will grow out of this princess phase, but a lot of them won't, and it could affect them in the future.  It could affect them in school or their self-esteem.  The industry is also to blame because they portray everything as very girly by having every toy they sell for girls in pink.  Also, how they portray the Disney princesses as beautiful, skinny, and white.  They all look like supermodels, and the industry helps portray that image from what they sell.  I thought Brittani's blog was right on, and I agreed with all the points that she made. 

Comments: Parents are a big part of the problem I think.  Especially fathers with their sons.  Boy's as young as 4 said their father's would say that it was bad if their son's played with girls toys.  Just because their father uses tools that means they have to use tools too!  The fathers try to poor masculinity into their sons.  In the article one of Orenstein's friends bragged about how he got his daughter hot wheels, and when is son asked for a tutu he refused to get it for him.  That is unfair in my opinion he is playing favoritism towards his daughter by letting her play with something that is considered masculine, and if his son wanted something that was considered feminine he refused.  Like I said in my blog children should be able to play with whatever they want it won't make them any less of a boy or a girl, and it won't affect them in the future.  The gender stereotype of masculine and feminine need to change. Look at link I put earlier in the article if you haven't already.

Monday, October 15, 2012

Who wants to go to breakfast tomorrow morning with the class?

Hey everyone! We are planning on going out to breakfast tomorrow morning during the time we would normally have class at either friendlys, ihop or somewhere else. Let me know if you want to go.

Sunday, October 7, 2012

Unlearning the Myths that Bind Us

Unlearning the Myths that Bind Us by: Linda Christensen
Talking Points #4
Reflection:
 
This was a very difficult article for me to read.  I was a kid who always loved cartoons, Disney movies, and Disney World in Florida.  I still occasionally like to watch cartoons now, and I'm 19 years old.  Now, that they mention it in the article I do realize how they depicted certain characters.  All the different stereotypes that are depicted show people of color, fat people, women, and other types of people in bad ways.  So, when children watch this they get this image in their head of how these types of people act.  No one acts different because of what they look like all people are the same and deserve to be treated the same. 
One part during the article was when a couple of the students mentioned how they never see the main character as African American, and they thought the Disney movies would be better if the main character isn't only depicted as white.  It wouldn't change how we learned from it.  If the main character is black or white like in Cinderella the story will still end the same.  It will end happily ever after the girl will get her prince charming just by changing how she looks, and making herself look more beautiful.  Happiness doesn't just come from getting a man, and changing your clothes and hairstyle.  This brings me back to SCWAAMP.  Especially the "A" in scwaamp" which means Ablebodiedness.  Everyone has this image of beautiful as you should be skinny or just look like a barbie doll.  That is also what a movie like Cinderella is trying to get across just because of how beautiful you are means that you will have a happy ending in life.  The world is not like that.  I wish everyone could have a happy ending, but its not that easy.  You have to work hard in life, and achieve your goals, and find someone you love.  Not everything is based on how you look.  The link I put there shows exactly the point I'm trying to get across about how a Disney princess like Cinderella sends the wrong message to young children. 
Comments:  I will always love Disney movies and cartoons because I grew up watching them.  They do send bad messages to children, but when they are that young they don't realize what they are learning.  When they get older I hope they realize that the messages these movies sent were wrong.  I wish that they didn't have these types of messages in the stories.  Disney movies had all sorts of subliminal messages that I didn't know about.  Why would they put those in their movies when they know the general audience for them are children?  I hope that in newer cartoons they send better messages to children, and I don't think that these movies should be taken away from them all in all.  I just think at some point children should learn about the messages these movies were depicting, and realize it was wrong to depict them that way.  

Sunday, September 30, 2012

GLSEN- Day of Silence

Day of Silence by: GLSEN
Talking Points #3
Reflection:
The article that I read was about The Day of Silence.  For those of you that don't know what the Day of Silence is, it is the largest single student-led action towards creating safer schools for all, no matter what your sexual orientation is. What happens during the Day of Silence is students across the country take a vow of silence to show the silencing effect of anti-LGBT bullying and harassment in schools.  The first ever Day of Silence occurred at the University of Virginia in 1996, and as of 2008, 8,000 other schools including middle schools, high schools, and universities have participated in the Day of Silence.  I think that is amazing how many schools now that show their support using the Day of Silence.  I bet even more schools do the Day of Silence since it is now 2012.  I think all schools should implement the Day of Silence it's a great way to stop the bullying against gays, bisexuals, lesbians, and transgendered. 
I remember when they were having the Day of Silence at my high school one year.  I didn't know what it was, but I participated anyways because a lot of my friends were doing it.  Once I found out why everyone was taking a vow of silence I continued to do my vow of silence because I wanted to show support to all of those who were bullied or harassed.  I remembered being asked by multiple students if I was gay?  I didn't respond obviously, but I remember thinking that who cares if I'm gay, straight, or bisexual I'm just showing my support because I don't think that it's right for anyone of any sexual orientation to be bullied. 
While in school students can take the vow of silence, and most teachers will allow them not to talk for the day.  In the case if a teacher asks the student a question on this day the student can't refuse to answer, and they must talk. Lastly, there are many ways to get involved with this in your schools, groups, sororities or whatever this article shows many ways to get involved.  I think that schools and colleges should have this. I would like to learn more through classes at RIC.  Everyone should get involved!
Comment: There is this one quote that I saw that I thought I should put on here that is very true! "I hate the word 'homophobia'. It's not a phobia. You're not scared. You're just an asshole!"
This video that I'm attaching is a Public Service Announcement for the day of silence.
 
 

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Aria and Teaching Multilingual Children

Aria by: Richard Rodriguez
Teaching Multilingual Children by: Virginia Collier

Talking Points #2
Argument:
In my opinion, Collier argues that you should not take away a child's first language to try and get them to understand a public language. For example, if a child's first language or the language they speak at home is Spanish, don't make them stop speaking it just to learn the public language of English at school.  It has its pros and cons.  It is a good thing to become a better English learner because you will be able to understand and be able to participate more in school.  It can also be bad because it can take away the communication you have with your family if your parents can only speak Spanish.  In Collier's article Guideline #3 states, "Don't teach a second language in any way that challenges or seeks to eliminate the first language." What this is trying to say is by teaching students a second language, don't take them away from their native language.  In school, it should be okay to be able to speak more than one language.  Being bilingual or multilingual can be very important to a child's future and it may even help them.  In the article Aria, Richard was told he could only speak a public language which was English.  It got him and his family away from his native language, so he could only be fluent in one language.  When he went to school and learned only in English.  What happens in this article is exactly what Collier argues.  He shouldn't have been taken away from his first language just to speak English and make the nuns happy.  He lost his individuality by doing that.  Overall, Collier thinks that children should not be taken away from their first language to learn a public language it could hurt them in the future, and it could also take away their individuality! The link there goes to another article about how learning a second language means losing the first language, and I thought it was very interesting. 
 
Comments: I think knowing more than one language is really a better thing for most children.  In America, we are starting to use more and more Spanish in everyday life.  So, if you are able to speak both English and Spanish in America it can be very useful to you nowadays.  Also, I was surprised when I read that becoming stronger in your primary language was better than becoming stronger in both your primary language and a secondary language.  Apparently, being strong in your primary language can help transfer to a secondary language. Was anyone else surprised by that?  Lastly, just being strong in a secondary language can be the worst thing for a child, and I completely understood that.  Overall, this article was very interesting to read and I learned a lot about multilingual children, and how their primary and secondary languages affect them.

Sunday, September 16, 2012

White Privilege

White Privilege:  Talking Points #1
Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack by: Peggy McIntosh

Quotes:

"White Privilege is like an invisible weightless knapsack of special provisions, maps, passports, code books, visas, clothes, tools and blank checks." (Pg. 1)
What I think this means is that all white people have privileges that others don't.  What McIntosh means by this is, black people don't have these privileges, and white people didn't have to do anything to earn them.  Also, I think it will be hard for black people to ever get the same privileges.  This ties in with the article because of the 26 conditions that are easier for white people to count on than they are for black people. 

"If I should need to move, I can be pretty sure of renting or purchasing housing in an area that I can afford and in which I would want to live."(Pg. 2)
This is one of the 26 conditions McIntosh lists in the article.  It means if she or another white person wanted to move she could move wherever she wanted without worrying if she had to afford it or not.  Also, the thing that is being implied that African Americans do not have this privilege like white people do.  They can't just get up and move where they want to.  They do have to worry about affording a place to live, so they have to live where they can afford to, so most of the time they do not have a choice.  McIntosh again is showing how white people have more privilege. 

"Whiteness protected me from many kinds of hostility, distress, and violence, which I was being subtly trained to visit, in turn, upon people of color." (Pg. 4)
When I first read this quote the first thing that came to my mind was "SCWAAMP."  Whiteness is the "W" in SCWAAMP.  Whiteness has more, power and privilege over any other race according to McIntosh and many other people in our world.  Whiteness protected her from all sorts of hostility and violence because they have more privilege than anyone else. That is what this whole article is about white people have so much privilege, and they don't even realize it.  They should not take these things for granted.

One point that I would like to bring up is where it said, "most students in the United States do not see Whiteness as a racial identity."  I never thought of it as a racial identity either until I read this article.  It definitely is a racial identity that has more privilege than any other race, but it shouldn't be that way.  When I thought of racism I always thought of how people where racist against black people or other races.  Whether it was the segregation or how poorly black people were treated back in the day.  Now I agree Whiteness is definitely a racial identity just like any other.  Most white people think that racism doesn't affect them because they are not people of color.  Racism does affect them because white people get judged just like any other race does because of all their privileges.  Each race has their own privileges, and according to McIntosh, whiteness has more privileges than any other race, and a lot of the time they don't even realize it! The link I put there is an article by Audrey Thompson about Whiteness Theory, and I thought it was interesting to read, and had to do with what we read for class.